Bush the Elder’s “Vision Thing”

Share this nybbleShare on Facebook
Tweet about this on Twitter
Share on LinkedIn
A colleague suggested a TED talk by Simon Simek on “leadership.”  Can any talk or book about “leadership” be credible?
I am suspicious of someone who casually proposes that humans are motivated “by biology not psychology.” As if these could be cleanly partitioned off from one another.

I can perhaps overlook that oversimplification.

But most organizations “believe” many things. Concurrence of employee/vendor teams, if it could be measured, would surely cut across many beliefs and ideas. It would be difficult to prove that what motivates people is a directly causative to success of a given enterprise. Being motivated can lead to good as well as bad results. There are good and bad, successful and unsuccessful visions that can be communicated (or mis-communicated) to prospective cult members. Many a startup with great vision, collective commitment, and focus on “why,” not just “what” — will fail to make the cut.

Inspirational, powerful rhetoric is great (and its absence is painful), but show me what Simek in his talk disparagingly refers to as “the 12 point plan,” too. A core principle in understanding how people operate, I believe, is the notion that knowledge, and the pursuit of it in an enterprise, is intersubjective. That means, at some level, distrusting not only the expressed beliefs of others, but one’s own instincts to believe.

Maybe Simek it simply reiterating what Bush the Elder was said to have commented about “the vision thing.” Give it its due, but no more.

About knowlengr
Read previous post:
Recruiting #fail: On Recruiting for Proficiency

What follows is a position description received this month from a firm  -- not a recruiter. Required Technical Skills: Proficiency...